In a recent survey of more than 1,000 business executives, 96% said that it would be useful for new hires to be able to have constructive conversations with those that disagree with them. The perceived value of this skill is unsurprising. According to the Society for Human Resource Management’s Civility Index, people experience more than 207 million acts of incivility every day in the United States, including 68 million inside the workplace. Each incident consumes an average of 36 minutes of productive time, and together these acts cost U.S. organizations an estimated $2.1 billion daily in lost productivity and absenteeism.
This erosion of civility coincides with a significant generational shift. By 2030, Gen Z will make up nearly a third of the American workforce, yet 75% of employers report dissatisfaction with recent Gen Z hires, and only 28% believe recent graduates arrive well-prepared in durable skills such as communication, conflict resolution, and self-regulation. One in three employees says generational differences directly contribute to incidents of incivility. The result is a widening perception gap between young workers and the employers who hire them, with real costs in turnover, disengagement, and workplace culture.
Colleges and universities have responded by expanding civil discourse and dialogue programming over the past several years, but participation typically remains voluntary. The students most likely to benefit — those least inclined to engage across difference — are also the most likely to opt out. Linking these skills explicitly to career success offers one clear way to broaden participation, since graduates are consistently motivated to build and signal the skills employers value most.
To explore this connection, AVDF partnered with the SHRM Foundation in early 2025 to convene higher education leaders and employers around a shared question: what does it take to prepare students not just to debate ideas, but to collaborate productively across real workplace differences? A $250,000 AVDF grant supported the resulting work, which drew on more than 20 stakeholder consultations and a national convening in Chicago of roughly 50 students, educators, employers, and ecosystem partners.
That work produced the published roadmap, Campus to Career Ready: A Roadmap for Civility and Career Readiness, released in late August 2026. The research reframed the underlying problem. Rather than a “skills gap,” stakeholders converged on a coordination gap, in which students, educators, and employers largely agree on which skills matter but lack the shared language and credentialing systems to recognize and reinforce them.
The SHRM Foundation frames the roadmap as a living framework rather than a finished product, intended to evolve through pilot programs, structured feedback, and continued cross-sector collaboration. A new AVDF grant, described below, begins that work.
This work is now reaching a national audience. In a November 2026 Forbes feature, “The Job Skill Employers Need Most May Be The Ability To Disagree,” journalist Alison Griffin examined why employers consistently name this skill as a priority yet struggle to find or measure it in new hires. A recent survey of employers shows that only 44% are very confident colleges are in fact building that skill. “I don’t know if they’re just overly optimistic that this next wave of graduates is going to help them with their civility problems in the workplace,” Ashley Finley of The American Association of Colleges and Universities (AAC&U) told Forbes.
Griffin’s reporting pointed to two AVDF-funded efforts as part of the emerging response. Alongside the SHRM Foundation roadmap, AVDF also supports a Durable Skills Pilot, launched this fall by Unify America, a nonpartisan nonprofit that pairs college students across political and institutional differences for structured, one-on-one conversations. Running from September through December 2026 at five institutions, the pilot is testing whether durable skills like active listening and working across difference can be assessed and documented with the same rigor employers apply to other job skills. Roughly 500 students are participating, each receiving a personalized report mapping their conversations to 21 durable skills drawn from AAC&U’s Civic Engagement VALUE Rubric and NACE’s Career Readiness Competencies. Initial findings are expected in early 2027.
AVDF’s newest investment continues this work. The SHRM Foundation was recently awarded a $150,000 AVDF grant to carry the roadmap’s priorities into practice. The project titled, “From Campus to Career Ready: Defining the Construct for Civility and Workplace Readiness” begins by convening a working group of higher education and business leaders. The group will develop mock scenarios that capture incivility on campus and in the workplace and document the specific skills needed to navigate each one. That process will produce a shared definition of civility across both settings and a clear account of the skills that compose it. SHRM and AAC&U will then work with faculty and other higher education experts to design pilot interventions that build those skills, along with instruments to measure whether students acquire them.
The approach rests on a practical insight: colleges are more likely to offer these programs when they can show that the programs develop the durable skills employers want, and students are more likely to seek them out when they see them as preparation for the workforce. AAC&U’s Ashley Finley told Forbes she sees the work as groundwork for micro-credentials that both employers and institutions can trust. “That’s not a one and done,” Finley said. “That’s skill building.”
Together, these investments point to the same thesis: the ability to disagree productively is a durable and teachable skill — and the organizations that learn to measure it will be the ones that can prove it to employers.
“Civility is not a soft skill — it is the connective tissue that determines whether new graduates can collaborate, adapt, and lead once they enter the workforce,” said AVDF President and CEO Michael Murray. “Forbes’ coverage this week only underscores what we’ve seen in our own grantmaking: employers know exactly what they’re looking for. Our job is to help the field prove it can be taught, measured, and trusted,” Murray said.
Back to all Stories